Kantianism utilitarianism contractarianism

The basic thing is that rational beings should follow a common set of laws or principles expressing their self-respect and their respect for one another as ends in themselves and the idea that they are legislators in a common of the laws to which they are subject. He sought to move philosophy beyond the debate between Rationalism and Empiricismand he attempted to combine those two apparently contradictory doctrines into one overarching system.

Based off your example, Kantian ethics would deem your actions taking cigarettes from people who are smoking not morally worthy.

Western philosophy

Luckily, our species will not die out if everyone is permitted not to have children, since enough people want to have children.

It does not matter what you want, you are still obligated to do y. He provided the first real opposition to the Materialism of the Pre-Socraticsand he developed doctrines such as Platonic RealismEssentialism and Idealismincluding his important and famous theory of Forms and universals he believed that the world we perceive around us is composed of mere representations or instances of the pure ideal Forms, which had their own existence elsewhere, an idea known as Platonic Realism.

But it could still be framed as a positive-sum bargain. Pleasure and Kantianism utilitarianism contractarianism Good Life: I think most people understand his argument as follows: There are many ways in which the theories we are covering can be classified however for our purposes we will think of Kantian ethics as a contractualist theory of ethics.

A combination of the two, or possibly other theories we are yet to learn, will make for a better ethical stance in my opinion.

Normative ethics

Then you go from just your community to all humanity. It just seems like there is too much gray area in Kantian ethics that could potentially still allow individuals to take advantage of others. Other consequentialists add the intrinsic values of friendship or love, freedom or ability, life, virtue, and so on.

Act consequentialism is the claim that an act is morally right if and only if that act maximizes the good, that is, if and only if the total amount of good for all minus the total amount of bad for all is greater than this net amount for any incompatible act available to the agent on that occasion.

Towards the end of the Age of Enlightenmentthe German philosopher Immanuel Kant caused another paradigm shift as important as that of Descartes years earlier, and in many ways this marks the shift to Modern philosophy. But in contractualism the rules of morality arise by an idealized mutual agreement wherein all the members of the moral community agree to principles that benefit everyone.

It is deontogical but the duties are derived in a contractual way which, I believe, makes it more appropriate to classify it as a contractualist theory. Yet classic utilitarians accepted them all.

Or I might prefer to die merely because I am clinically depressed. Although he was careful to claim not to have all the answers himself, his constant questioning made him many enemies among the authorities of Athens who eventually had him put to death.

Maybe he does not notice the rot on the hamburger he feeds to his kids which makes them sick.

A Series Of Unprincipled Exceptions

Yet another argument for a kind of consequentialism is contractarian. Freedom and Reason, London: I might prefer to drink the liquid in a glass because I think that it is beer, though it really is strong acid.

Why Atheists Lose Debates

He was tried for corrupting the youth and impiety by the Greek democracy. If Mill is correct about this, then utilitarians can say that we ought to give much more to charity, but we are not required or obliged to do so, and failing to do so is not morally wrong. Agent-relativity is also supposed to solve other problems.

Table of Contents

Never treat anyone merely as a means to an end. Mention should also be made of Deconstructionism often called just Deconstructiona theory of literary criticism that questions traditional assumptions about certainty, identity and truth, and looks for the underlying assumptions both unspoken and implicitas well as the ideas and frameworks, that form the basis for thought and belief.

Ethics of care or relational ethics, founded by feminist theoristsnotably Carol Gilliganargues that morality arises out of the experiences of empathy and compassion.

Can we do otherwise. For predecessors, see Schneewind If consequentialists define consequences in terms of what is caused unlike Sosathen which future events count as consequences is affected by which notion of causation is used to define consequences. Some utilitarians respond by arguing that we really are morally required to change our lives so as to do a lot more to increase overall utility see KaganP.


Such consequentialists do not just add up values; they look at patterns. Moreover, according to those who prefer a broader definition of consequentialism, the narrower definition conflates independent claims and obscures a crucial commonality between agent-neutral consequentialism and other moral theories that focus exclusively on consequences, such as moral egoism and recent self-styled consequentialists who allow agent-relativity into their theories of value SenBroomePortmorePeirce and developed and popularized by William James and John Dewey.

Post-Structuralism is a reaction to Structuralismwhich stresses the culture and society of the reader over that of the author.

I morally should save my wife straightaway without calculating utilities. Contractualism vs. Contractarianism.

Contractualism, a term used to describe Kantian style social contract theory, shares a set of features with contractarianism, or Hobbesian style social contract theory, which often leads them both to be classified as different types. April 13, Ethics - Contractarianism John Messerly John Rawls’ “Hypothetical” Contract A thinker who espoused contractarian moral philosophy was the Harvard philosopher John Rawls, whose book A Theory of Justice is the single most influential philosophical ethics text of the past thirty years.

Kantianism vs Utilitarianism Those who are not students of philosophy, words like utilitarianism and Kantianism may sound alien, but for those who try to tackle questions of ethics and wisdom, these two represent important viewpoints.

Atheists often lose public debates with theists, especially when going up against heavyweights like William Lane Craig. I don’t know of an atheist losing a debate to someone who denies evolution. That’s safe ground because the atheist can stick to. Kantian Ethics and Contractualism Kantian ethics is one tradition of ethical theory within the broader contractualist tradition, although for much of the past several hundred years it has been the main representative of contractualism.

The words "moral" and "ethics" (and cognates) are often used interchangeably. However, it is useful to make the following distinction: Morality is the system through which we determine right and wrong conduct -- i.e., the guide to good or right conduct.

Ethics is the philosophical study of Morality. What, then, is a moral theory?

Kantianism utilitarianism contractarianism
Rated 5/5 based on 21 review
Western philosophy - Wikipedia